Wild Truffle Pizzeria and Italian Bistro opened July 13th 2009. A few weeks ago, my wife had lunch at Wild Truffle with a friend. She liked it and suggested we go back for dinner. Since the grand opening was only a little over a month ago, I had not heard much about the restaurant. I was not sure what to expect ,so I asked around on twitter. I heard positive feedback from happy patrons of Wild Truffle and from the Olive Cellar, which happens to be a supplier to the restaurant. If you are interested in learning more about the Olive Cellar or Taste of the Fox Valley, you can follow on Twitter @theoliveceller or Taste of the Fox Valley at @wallaper. Back to business, so we arrived at Truffle around 7:30. A little late for most, but that is when our childcare arrived!

Atmosphere: As we pulled into the full parking lot my wife said “you know this is the only business in this new strip mall right?” Really? This busy this late on a Thursday night? This is a good sign and we are in no particular hurry to get home.
We were greeted by the hostess who took our name and said it would be about a 20 minute wait. At this point, we thought no problem, we will be at the bar. 20 minutes is the perfect amount of time to wait for a table. This is exactly when things got interesting! The hostess informed there is no bar available for patrons waiting for tables. Ok, now I am in shock. This is Wisconsin people. No bar is like a night without stars, a day without sun.. ok, you get the picture. There is a lovely outdoor seating area and the weather was comfortable, so we said, we will have a drink on the patio. We were then told that the patio is reserved for diners enjoying their meals.. We were then asked to step outside, yes I said outside to the parking lot. They said a waiter would come to the parking lot to take our drink order. So we stepped back outside and joined about 6 others standing around. Luckily they sent a waiter out to take drink orders while we waited. I have to say that we did get some decent laughs out of this experience.
Let’s talk about some of the specifics of the restaurant.. Well from what we can remember as we are in the parking lot : ) As you enter Wild Truffle, you will be immediately greeted by a hostess in the main dining area. Unique tile covered tables fill the room until you get to the far end where there is a good size white granite bar for diners. What is awesome about eating at the bar area is the wood fired oven and the chefs are right there making the various entrees. Every entree is prepared in the wood fired oven, which is a great feature. The chefs preparing the entrees and pizza serve as a great source of entertainment.
The walls are painted a rich color of green with framed artistic art of various food related items. The ceiling is also unlike anything I have seen locally. It reminds me of a pergola you would see above a outdoor deck with lighting above that, very nice touch. Everything is new and impressive. There is also some big band / Frank Sinatra music playing in the background. There is a large outdoor seating area which is located off of the main dining area.
Food: From the home page of Wild Truffles website “Our mission is being known as the finest artisan pizzeria in U.S.” The menu here is not large but it sure is great. While glancing over the “starters” you see items like sweet Italian sausage, goat cheese and wood fired shrimp. They have salads, a few pasta dishes like butternut squash ravioli and lemon shrimp spaghetti…yum! The main portion of the menu as you would guess is pizza.
We decided to start with an appetizer before our dinner arrived, tonight our choice was Wood-Fired Tomato & Wisconsin Goat Cheese Fondue with smoked garlic-rubbed crostinis. Other then the crostinis being a little hard and chewy it was a great appetizer.
My wife ordered the baby spinach salad consisting of wood roasted crimini mushrooms, balsamic onions, roasted red peppers, white truffle champagne vinaigrette, herbed ricotta and toasted pine nuts.
I had to try the pizza so decided on the Sweet Italian Sausage pizza. The toppings are roasted crimini mushrooms, balsamic onions, fire-roasted tomato sauce, whole milk mozzarella, imported Italian grana, padano and Italian parsley. Makes me hungry just remembering it!

Both meals were delivered and looked beautiful. Well, a salad is a salad but my pizza looked amazing! The first thing about the pizza that catches your eye is the crust. It was a perfect golden brown, puffy and what looked like a thin layer of butter on the crust. I had to dig into it before I could even snap any pictures. Click the pics for a larger view. The pizza was good but I was not wowed, there was just something missing. It needed a little sweetness or some saltiness, just something to make your mouth wake up and say yum! Dont get me wrong, this pizza was good. Just not as good as it looked.
For desert we ordered Mt. Vesuvius Italian Red Raspberry Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Gelato. This was delicious in every way, nothing but happy.

Conclusion: This Pizzeria has alot going for it and we will definitely be back. Service here was great, and the prices were reasonable. An appetizer, 1 pizza, 1 dinner salad, desert, 2 beers and 2 glasses wine was a total of $60. Take a look at the menu links below for more details.
I was lucky enough to talk to the owner during out visit and I asked him what he is doing about the lack of a waiting area and the lack of a bar for patrons. He mentioned that there is more room next to the current restaurant and they are considering an addition. I could tell by the look on his face he has heard that question a time or 10.
Wild Truffle information:
Web site - wildtrufflepizza.com
Phone Number - 920-733-3330
Fax - 920-733-3447
Address - 5120 W. Michaels Dr. Appleton, WI 54913
Hours - Mon - Thur 11:00am - 10pm
Fri - Sat 11:00am - 11:00pm
Menus (pdf) - Main Drink
Google Map
Brian $9-$15, Casual, Italian