This week we wanted to find a restaurant that was not a chain and something not as fancy as a supper club. We decided to give Beefeaters a try. Beefeaters opened in November 2007 and is located by US 41 and Ballard Road. It wasn’t until I started browsing through the menu that I found out that they are affiliated with Good Company, Pullmans and Nan Sorellas. I have to admit that I was a bit disappointed with the Pullman’s connection because I have never been impressed with the food quality their, but lets save that for a future review.
Atmosphere: Beefeaters calls itself a British themed restaurant serving up classic pub dishes with their own twist, as well as American favorites. My wife called classifies it as “British invasion meets modern day sports bar.” Since this restaurant was built in recently, the interior and exterior is both attractive and well maintained. One of the first things that caught my eye was the gas fire pit located on the outdoor patio. Very nice touch and one that I have not seen before.

The British theme is a mainstay throughout Beefeaters. Some of the specifics include a classic red phone booth filled with British police helmets, large flags, writing on the walls and various Beatles memorabilia. In the dining room where we sat was a nice fireplace from floor to ceiling and British artwork on the walls. You can get the idea from the photos below. We both appreciated the “Brits to Yanks” glossary on the back of the menu, it made for a good laugh. We thought the high back booths were a nice compliment. You might be wondering why we value the high back booth? Not only are they great for privacy, but a huge bonus for dining out with small children. The bar area is very stylish with its wood floors, and dark wood bar accented with copper beer taps. The pub style table is available in the bar area if you prefer to enjoy your meal in a more bar like atmosphere. The are a few flat screen televisions to catch important games such as the Packers or Brewers.

Food: The menu is quite large (see link below), it covers all the standards and then some. They have a few unique things on the menu like grilled paninis and signature dishes which are their version of a few British classics. London Broil, Shephard’s pie and of course fish ‘n’ chips to name a few. After spending some time looking over the menu I decided on one of my favorite’s, the reuben. Reuben’s are hit or miss for me, it seems like they are either great or just dry and tasteless. It came with a choice of waffle chips or cole slaw, that is a no brainer. Fries of any sort will always win out! The large menu honestly is always a concern for me. I have found that when a restaurant offers too many options, they do most things average at best. I always prefer to see fewer choices. My rationale is the jack of all trades master of none philosophy.
My wife ordered the black and blue burger which was topped with blue cheese and garnished with pickle and tomato. We kicked the evening off with an appetizer of spicy buffalo dip and were surprised when complimentary bread and scones arrived.
One a scale of 1-10, with 10 being outstanding, I would say the spicy buffalo dip and chips was about a 5. It was not fully blended and was laced with many hot spots from the microwave preparation. It had a good flavor, if you are looking to cure a salt craving. The scones and bread that was brought out with the appetizer was awesome. Much better than the appetizer anyday! Only problem with the scones and bread is that it is so filling, but very delicious.
On to my entree…..drum roll please…………….I am pleased to announce my reuben was very good. As I mentioned earlier, it is either hit or miss with me in the reuben department and this one was definitely a hit. The waffle fries delicious, seasoned well and very tasty, they did not last long. My wife’s black and blue burger was about a 5, similar as the appetizer. It was Ok, just not great. The blue cheese was sprinked in the top and I was hoping that it would have been inside the burger, not used as a garnish. It was a bit dry, but the presentation was good, but nothing to write home about that is for sure. She ordered the mashed potatoes and those were excellent. You know it is a good sign when you can see about half a stick of butter melted on top! Click image below to enlarge.

Conclusion: Overall the food was good and so was the price. Our bill was around 40.00 for the both of us and that included one soda, two beers, two entrees and an appetizer. If you are looking for an good meal in an nice but a little quirky atmosphere, then Beefeaters is your place. This is not the type of restaurant you want to seek out if you are in anyway attempting to watch your caloric intake. The food was definitely prepared with lots of butter, cheese and other good stuff..I mean health hazards.
Beefeaters information:
Address - 2331 E Evergreen Dr. - Appleton, WI 54913
Phone - (920) 730-8300
Web Site - beefeaterspub.com
email - contact@beefeaters.com or web form here
Menu - pdf
Google Map
Brian $16-$22, $9-$15, Casual